Growth, Experience & Conversion
← All stories

Church · St. Louis, MO · Brand positioning · User experience

Unfailing Love Christian Church

A site built for a church that grew to two campuses1

The Unfailing Love homepage: "A Place to Grow in Faith and Belong in Community" with service times for both campuses beside a worship leader singing with her hands raised
Industry
Church
Location
St. Louis and Florissant, MO
Team size
Two campuses, 320+ members
What we did
Brand identity, website, member portal, Planning Center and Church Online integration
Timeline
Rebrand 2022, new site 2025

Where they started

Unfailing Love had grown into a young, energetic church, but its clip art logo and website still looked like where it started. We rebranded in 2022. Then the church kept growing, and after a church growth workshop, Pastor Jason and Tim both saw it: the site was built for the church they were, not the one they were becoming. Leaders and members trying to join small groups had the hardest time, because the site didn't connect to the tools the church actually used. Tim serves as the church's head of marketing and digital experience, so he knew those gaps firsthand.

Before and after: the old Unfailing Love logo, a clip art cross with purple cloth and script lettering, beside the new circular mark with the line Experience Love, Share Love, Spread Love

Where people were slipping away

We walked the path their guests and members take, one stop at a time.

  1. Hear about themSlip point: The old logo and materials didn't look like the church people met in person.
  2. Look them upSlip point: A first-time guest had no clear path through the site.
  3. Try to understandSlip point: Ministries and departments were hard to find, and some led nowhere.
  4. Look for a next stepSlip point: Members looking for small groups had no clear way to join.
  5. Reach outSlip point: Forms and prayer requests didn't reach the systems the church used.
  6. Follow upSlip point: Follow-up depended on information the site didn't pass along.

What we changed

Three fixes, in the order that mattered most.

  1. What we saw: Members and guests couldn't tell where to go next, or who to talk to.

    What we did: Every ministry and department now has one clear next step, and each one goes to the right person. Guests get a Connect Card, and members get pathways for baptism, groups, serving and giving.

    The Unfailing Love Next Steps page: "We'd Love To Connect With You" with a Connect Card button beside a photo of members talking, above the Next Step Pathways section
  2. What we saw: Pastor Jason wanted members to work through the MasterLife study series, and there was nowhere to do it.

    What we did: We built a custom member area on the site. Each member gets their own private profile, a recommended growth plan, and MasterLife progress that saves as they go.

    The Unfailing Love member dashboard: a welcome message, MasterLife study progress with a Continue button, and a five step recommended growth plan
  3. What we saw: The site didn't talk to the tools the church runs on, so information had to be passed along by hand.

    What we did: We connected the site to Planning Center and the Church Online Platform. Forms update member profiles on their own, and a prayer request during the live stream reaches the team right away.

    The Live Like Jesus small groups page: this week's session video, a list of past sessions and a Join a small group button

The result

Since the new site launched, the church gets fewer questions and more excitement about what's next, and Pastor Jason keeps hearing from other church leaders who want the same experience for their church.

Members, up from 50 at the original campus
320+1
from 50 to 320+
Campuses, with North County added
21
from 1 to 2
Visits sent to the church's online services in the last year
2462
Visits sent to Planning Center to sign up and connect
1662

Next story

All stories
Jennyfer Christman of Pivot X, an executive coach for leadership transitions and burnout prevention

Pivot X

Executive coaching · St. Louis, MO

From first site to preferred partner

A brand new coaching business, and a first website sized to where it was.

Jenn was just starting Pivot X and wasn't sure she had enough to start strong. We kept it simple: clear StoryBrand messaging and one focused page, built so she could grow into it.

Focused page to launch the brand, sized for a new business
1
Kinds of leaders it speaks to: executives, senior leaders, organizations
3
Clear next step on every screen: book a strategy call
1
Read the story about Pivot X

Sound like your business?

Let's walk your path together.

Start a conversation